Monday, February 21, 2011

Her Own Worst Enemy...

WHEN it comes to getting old, my standard advice is: surrender! Apologies to Dylan Thomas, but it's better to go quietly....just fold and walk away while you can still do so with some dignity. If I seem overly focused on the benefits of renouncing independence, I have good reasons.  My experience in the health care field, mostly with older adults, presented too many train wrecks to count—a  host of disasters, many of them avoidable, usually brought on by people’s stubborn insistence on not accepting the help they needed, always trying to do things “on their own” even when such an attitude becomes virtually suicidal.

I’ve said nothing so far about my mother, who died in 2007. She spent the last nine years of her life in a nursing home, suffering, because she refused to move out of her house when she should have. A combination of living alone, being confined to a wheelchair and unable to manage most of her basic activities set the stage; a defective lamp that caught fire while she was in bed finalized the deal.  By sheer luck (if that’s the word) she was rescued by firefighters who that very day had been trained to use a new infrared detector that can locate people under water or in the thickest smoke.

Burned severely over one third of her body, she was in the ICU for weeks. Tube-fed, on a respirator and completely helpless, she was hit by multiple infections and a stroke. Amazingly, she pulled through but was never able to leave the nursing home, and on a regular basis made it clear she would rather be dead. It would not have been helpful at that point to mention that we’d warned her repeatedly of the dangers inherent in her living situation; we’d even found decent board and care homes that she could have afforded, but she always refused to leave “home” even though she needed plenty of support to stay there.

Our American obsession with independence and individuality—what we call freedom—becomes a trap when the elderly do their best to carry on alone after they’re clearly not able to. It’s not like this everywhere. In fact, years ago our own culture dealt with aging relatives differently.  When people became old and frail, they’d move in with their adult children (or nieces and nephews), and that was considered a good thing. But these days it’s almost unthinkable.

The results play themselves out daily throughout our society. An 82-year-old woman I know is so close to the edge, almost in free-fall, yet she won't accept reality. Living alone in a 2-story house, she has plenty of money and nobody to leave it to, but won't hire anyone (other than a twice-monthly housecleaner) to help. She's already had a couple of falls, and is so crippled she can hardly lurch across the room--she only makes it by clutching furniture the entire time. The fact that she can (barely) drag herself up and down the stairs and somehow stagger to her car gives her the idea that she's just fine, thank you, and can manage on her own... 

Yet she asks strangers passing by on the street if they could please carry her groceries upstairs. When she gets occasional visitors, the first thing she does after saying hello is to have them take out the stinking garbage since she can't do it herself. Bathing? I guess if sponge baths twice a week do the trick, good for her. Cooking? Forget it, she just orders takeout or has canned soup. The mere suggestion that she might hire an agency to send a bonded caregiver who could make her life much easier brings up a predictable response: "That's crazy, I don't know those people. And it would cost $100 a day." Does she know that a nursing home will cost her nearly $300 per day? That's where she's heading--unless she gets lucky and just breaks her neck falling down the stairs.

My parents, so far, are more intact, but they too are playing with fire.  I hope to be somewhat tactful on the day I tell them that they can’t continue in their current situation, that their desire for independence could result in their losing the very thing they're trying to preserve. And I can only hope they'll listen.

Monday, February 14, 2011

Who, Me Angry?

I call myself an angry caregiver, but what do I have to be angry about, given the relative ease of my situation? There are so many layers here. Perhaps I just don’t want to give up my spare time—pure selfishness. Or is it more along the lines of not wanting to take on a “parent” role with my parents? The fact of my not having children has placed me, more or less permanently, in the position of child (albeit adult) and maybe on some level I don’t want to leave my comfort zone.

Or it could be the realization that not having children means that as I reach the age of my parents, I won’t be able to rely on anyone other than paid helpers, if I can afford them. I might be feeling some resentment at providing something that I’ll never have the opportunity to enjoy.  Of course, kids don’t come with a lifetime guarantee of good behavior, and I’m aware of many older people whose adult children blithely abandon them, or worse, subject them to actual abuse. It’s hard to imagine the pain, the sense of betrayal that must engender.

Alternatively, I’m reminded of the “saints” among us—those of the sandwich generation who have both kids of their own and aging parents to care for simultaneously, and who manage it all with grace…at least outwardly.  But there is always a price attached to true sainthood. I guess I fall somewhere mid-range on the saint and spoiled brat scale. I’m helpful enough, but set limits, and occasionally make sharp comments or roll my eyes.

This past week’s visit was a lesson in successful multi-tasking, if not limit-setting.  The day began by driving my dad to the barber shop, and leaving him there while racing my stepmother to the bank, the pharmacy, and then (after picking up a patient, neatly-shorn father) finally heading to Safeway for the weekly shopping, all in a record two hours. 

No real complications, but while at the bank, the trust manager recommended a “personal appointment” with my stepmother sometime next week. She said she didn’t know when she could make an appointment as it all depended on when transportation would be available.  After hearing this, I tried not to show annoyance while pointing out that the short taxi ride to the bank might cost $8 from where they live and maybe, just maybe they could afford that. Her response: “Well, that’s more than the Sunshine Bus from the senior center costs.” Yes, I say, but they don’t drive you door to door at the exact time you want to go somewhere. I don't bother mentioning that they’ve never visited the senior center other than one time, under duress, to pick up the monthly activity calendar (just to see if they might like to go) and have never boarded the Sunshine Bus. 

But none of this matters, apparently. Again, I have to put myself in their position, wondering if I’d want to get involved with a senior center even if I were the right age. If there were no other options, maybe, but I can appreciate their reluctance. Luckily for them, my parents have options, and I am the one they’ve chosen.


Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Baby Steps


Everybody gets a gold star this week. I set limits patiently and kindly, and my parents actually agreed to try having their groceries delivered from Safeway.com. Of course, I still had to do the virtual shopping since my parents never joined the internet age, but it seems to have worked out and could become part of our routine now and then.

Grocery shopping per se has never been a problem for me. Unlike many people, I enjoy going to the store, meandering through random aisles just to see what might turn up. But shopping for other people, especially on a weekly basis, I find far less interesting.  In fact, it’s starting to feel like a reverse kind of the hell that parents shopping with toddlers must experience. 

“Are you sure you don’t need two rolls of paper towels? Didn’t you run out before? Oh—you want the sugar free, fat-free yogurt, not the low-fat. Gosh, a few extra calories might be a good thing in your case. No? OK. Yes, I already got the box of white zinfandel and the diet 7-Up. But you still need a quart of whole milk and ice cream—and I won’t forget the fat-free cottage cheese this time.”

It’s like shopping for Jack Spratt and his wife. My stepmother regards sugar and fat as hated adversaries (for no good reason; she is not diabetic and weighs less than 90 pounds) while my dad seeks them out: hot chocolate, whole milk and ice cream every day.  Both of them could stand to gain a good 10 to 15 pounds, but my nutritional advice falls on deaf ears. 

A spirit of rebellion, building toward blind rage, started to rear its head during our weekly trips to the store.  This can’t go on, I realized, so I calmly announced that I’m going to need one weekend per month “off,” and added that they’ll have to decide how to get their groceries that week. My stepbrother and his wife are almost never available on weekends, so the remaining options were hiring a helper or trying the delivery service.  For now they’ve chosen the latter. 

An occasional home care provider could greatly enrich their lives and would give them (and their family members) a measure of freedom and peace of mind. Money on that scale is not an issue to them, but the resistance to “outsiders,” those “people we don’t know” overrides logic. 

To a degree, I understand the reluctance to reveal their frailty—let alone their shopping habits—to strangers. But as they acknowledged, I do have a life. And I need to spend more of it outside of supermarkets.

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Counting our blessings...

So here’s the situation: my father is going on 87, and was diagnosed two years ago with early to moderate dementia. Add a history of chronic depression, some ongoing intestinal complaints, and that's pretty much what defines him these days. He’s always been quiet, veering toward withdrawn, traits that now have increased by an order of magnitude.  His life’s work as a community college professor (teaching speech and drama, which I never could imagine) ended when he retired at 61. 

My stepmother, a former kindergarten teacher some 7 years younger than dad, has endured a variety of  onslaughts, including a minor stroke, occasional seizures and atrial fibrillation that caused a series of TIAs (smaller temporary strokes). She enthusiastically makes up for my father’s silence; at times her constant stream of observations brings to mind the image of a dripping faucet. They recently left their home of 25 years in Southern California to move up north, closer to family.  That means me, my partner, my step-brother and his family. We all take part in the caregiving; my “shift” is usually on the weekends.

By almost anyone’s standard, my parents are not difficult or even especially needy. They don’t ask for favors very often, never whine or suggest that I should be doing more for them.  When I do help them out, they’re unfailingly appreciative. They’re generally the type of people who start their requests with “We don’t want to bother you, but….” or “Whenever it’s convenient, would you be able to…” As a caregiver, I must admit that I have it fairly good right now.  There’s no need for me to be there every day; I don’t have to cook or clean for them, and they’re still managing their own finances (albeit with questionable judgment). At the moment, there are no major medical problems, no adult diapers to contend with. In fact, there’s not much more than weekly shopping trips or taking them to a restaurant and an occasional appointment.  

To be honest, I can hardly be called a caregiver…but even so, there’s a creeping sense of rough times ahead, my knowledge that the trajectory of aging usually entails periods of relatively slow decline—even stability—punctuated by crises and major changes of status. But I can be grateful that, for now, they’re in better shape than most people in their age group.

I’m convinced that the key to successful aging is for older people to accept help when they need it. My parents certainly need more help than they’re getting, but their situation hasn’t become dire yet.  Lacking urgent cause to intervene, I must instead respect their need for independence (or what they see as independence.)  I must accept the fact that their meals are uninspired and at times inadequate; must be patient when they refuse to consider Meals on Wheels or even resist having occasional take-out delivered to them.  I do my best to monitor the situation, gathering as much information as I can about changes in their functional or physical status without appearing too intrusive. If I think a visit to the doctor or podiatrist is warranted, I help set it up or at least suggest they do so. It’s a delicate balance, and thus far, we’ve been lucky.

As parents are our first, and hopefully our best, teachers, mine continue to teach me. Not only in the “notes to self” sense of what to do should I reach their age and level of need, but also in the ongoing lessons of patience and acceptance. Not necessarily understanding, but accepting.

Saturday, January 29, 2011

How it all began....

I didn't start out hating old people--if anything, I idolized them...


From the beginning, older people were central to my life. The trusted, loving grandfather, the freethinking great-aunt and even the mythic figure of my great-grandmother, who, although she died before I was born, attained legendary status in our family for her strong character and practicality. She was the woman who never learned how to read or write, who spoke almost no English--but who had the ambition and foresight to work hard, save money and bring the whole family to the US from Russia shortly before the 1917 revolution.

Having been raised by a single father who worked full-time, I often found myself in the care of these older family members who selflessly gave me their attention and love as I made my way toward adulthood. They would tell me stories from their own childhood--hiding from Cossack raiders in the basement, watching their mother sell fish in the streets of Odessa while their father alternately beat them and studied religious texts. There was something pure and fierce about my attachment to them, and I felt it was mutual. As the first "real American" of the family, was I the representation of their hopes and dreams for a brighter future?  No matter, my fascination and love for old people was established and continued to grow over the years.

Either by chance or by choice, my first jobs after moving to the San Francisco Bay Area were working for  two different Alzheimer's day care programs. Spending time with a range of old people from many parts of the world, hearing the stories of their childhood (which they remembered more clearly than what they'd just eaten for lunch) brought me back to that familiar place of listening to the "old stories" and imagining what life must have been like.

So again, all this is to say that I never resented old people--never found them strange or boring--and always enjoyed the time I spent with them. At least, until now--as I find myself being relied on more and more heavily as a care provider for my father and stepmother as they proceed into what they optimistically call their "autumn years." Where does this resentment come from? Why do I balk at helping them in their pathetic attempts at remaining independent?  These questions and more will be explored in future posts. Thank you for reading, and feel free to comment.